Showing, not telling…(due Aug. 2)

Hey Friends,

Please share part of a story you’ve written or read that illustrates the idea of showing the reader information, not telling him/her.

Here’s my example from a story I wrote long ago for The Providence Journal (as near as I can remember it). The lead, something like:

“The town councilman and the aging widow had a deal: He would see to it that she never had to go into a nursing home; she would remember him in her will.

“So it was that (Town Councilman) seven years ago began taking supper each night to (Old Woman) in her rambling house on Sunderland Road. After she broke her hip for the second time, TC and his wife moved OW from the crumbling mansion, which lacks electricity and plumbing, into their rented house.

“TC did her banking. He oversaw her medical care. He washed her hair. He emptied her bedpan. He sat at her bedside and held her hand. And he fed her. He demonstrates by picking up a spoon and shaking it gently. “Fifty-four of them is in a bowl,” he says. “Fifty-four times to her mouth….”

Readers, I ask you: What about a man who counts the number of spoonfuls in a bowl of soup as he feeds this woman? How does he regard his task? Is he enjoying feeding her? Resenting it? Or….? You decide. As the writer, I haven’t told you how he feels about this – rather, through the use of his words and actions, I’ve shown you. You can decide whether he cared for the woman out of genuine concern and affection, or perhaps out of the hope of standing to gain by inheriting her substantial estate. (Or, as you read on, maybe some of both.)

Allowing readers to interpret the councilman’s motivation however they will makes for a more engaging, nuanced, richer and accurate story.

Your examples — or questions?

Colleen

Share

4 Comments

  1. June Wu
    08.02.10

    Here’s a story that ran in today’s paper that I thought would be appropriate for this post.

    http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2010/08/02/hundreds_of_soldiers_bid_farewell_to_families_in_worcester/

    I tried to use the vignettes in the story to illustrate what family members seeing their loved ones go off to war feels like.

  2. Molly Young
    08.05.10

    In my time on the business desk this summer and last summer, I’ve wrote about my fair share of studies. The numbers are important, but I’ve learned it’s more important to show what those numbers mean through human stories.

    For example, I co-wrote a story about recent statistics about the housing crisis on a state level. The story also cited current Making Home Affordable statistics. The numbers proved that Minnesotans were still struggling to afford housing. But more important, story of a woman who couldn’t make her mortgage payments, despite several attempts to sign up for the federal program. Her story showed readers why the numbers mattered.

  3. Mark Mock
    08.06.10

    This one is hard. I try my best to be visual but I suppose I am going to have to work on that a little bit more.

    This is a story about Puerto Rican families.
    http://www.democratandchronicle.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=20108010327

    And this one I tried to capture all the noises and movements at a Native American festival.
    http://www.democratandchronicle.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=20107250341

  4. Phillip Lucas
    08.13.10

    Super late, I know. But, here’s an example anyway:

    http://nola09.nytimes-institute.com/2009/05/28/homeowners-fault-chinese-drywall/

    And here’s a great example. It’s super long, but it’s really engaging and will keep you reading.

    http://arktype/read.php?id=23530&yr=2001&pass=read&xsl=read.xsl&bdysrch=anne!hull!divided!feast

Leave a comment